Valiant Shipyard bow out.
Shipyard bowed out of this season’s Scottish Cup following a 6-2 defeat to University of Stirling at Forthbank Stadium on Monday night. The scoreline was extremely harsh on Shippy as they went toe to toe with their Lowland League opponents for 75 minutes and had a couple of contentious decisions went their way, we may well have been looking at an entirely different outcome. Manager Lee Richardson stuck with the same starting eleven that had performed so well in the previous match against Kennoway Star Hearts as he looked to guide his team into the 2nd round of the cup.
Hopes of an upset didn’t get off to a good start as the students took the lead in the 4th minute when Finlay Moffett knocked the ball in at the near post and the goal stood despite legitimate claims for offside in the build-up. A quick break up the park saw Jordan Hunter’s cross blocked at the expense of a corner and from that set piece the ball wouldn’t drop kindly for a Shippy player in the box to get a strike away. Shipyard fell two behind in the 21st minute when a cross was allowed to be delivered to the back post and Alex Jeanes headed home from close range. Shippy quickly got back into the match when Innes Marr fired the ball into the net after a Jordan Galloway free-kick fell kindly for him. The game was now end to end with Stirling carving out some good chances while at the other end a penetrating run from Hunter set up Ben Anthony who saw his shot saved by Uni keeper Adam Buttigieg. Play quickly moved to the other end and Finlay Russell had to save bravely at the feet of the Stirling forward. Minutes later Russell could only look on as the ball was lobbed over his head and there was a collective sigh of relief from the Shipyard contingent as the ball cleared the bar and no more. Another shot was fired over in the 38th minute before Shippy stunned the hosts with an equaliser in two minutes before the interval and it was a disaster for Buttigieg as he dropped a simple cross at the feet of Hunter who gleefully smashed the ball into the net much to the delight of the large travelling support.

Russell did not appear after the interval due to a knee injury with Ryan Couser taking his place between the sticks. The first highly controversial moment occurred in the 56th minute when Galloway delivered a free kick towards the back post. As Marr rose to head the ball home he was clearly bundled over and as everyone inside the stadium waited for the penalty to be awarded there was apparently an offside flag raised, however, footage clearly shows that Marr was well onside, and a spot kick should have been given. Maybe also a red card as the challenge denied an obvious goal scoring opportunity. Couser saved well at the front post and watched on as a headed effort from a corner sailed over the bar. In the 69th minute Stirling captain Ben Heal launched into a dangerous tackle on Galloway that resulted in the Shippy man receiving lengthy treatment before being able to continue. It looked like a two footed challenge; however, the referee deemed a yellow card would suffice. From the resultant free kick Darrell Anthony’s delightful effort was brilliantly saved by Buttigieg as he tipped the ball over the bar. Stirling regained the lead in the 76th minute when Moffett rifled home a free kick from 18 yards and it looked like a tall order from there on in for Shippy to get back level, as they seemed to be tiring. That proved to be the case as substitute Nathan Tallen netted a fourth from around ten yards. Tallen then tapped home number five after Couser had blocked a shot with Shippy appeals for offside falling on deaf ears. Couser then saw red after getting involved with an opponent as he attempted to make a clearance at the edge of the box. As Couser was on a sub keeper B. Anthony was forced to take the gloves for the closing stages, and he was beaten by a low shot from Sam Martin five minutes into added time.
Richardson was naturally disappointed with the result but found plenty of positives when he spoke after the match “I am proud of my team tonight. There were some very good individual performances out there tonight. Jordan Hunter was giving them all sorts of problems but unfortunately, I had to sub him given the punishment he had taken all night, with very little protection from the officials.” He went on to say “how we never got a penalty when Marrzy was barged in the box I will never know. There was some talk of offside, however, the footage shows that was absolute nonsense. It’s a penalty all day long and probably a red card for denying a goal scoring opportunity. I would love an explanation on that one. The challenge on Jordan Galloway was a shocker; the guy was out of control with both feet off the ground. Jordan was very lucky not to get seriously injured. The boys can take a lot from that match. They matched a Lowland League team for the majority of the game and on another night, it might have been oh so different had we got a couple of decisions to go our way.”
We are back in league action on Saturday (04/10/2025) as we make the trip to West Linton to face Linton Hotspur for the very first time. Kick off at New Moor Road is at 2.30pm.
University of Stirling: A. Buttigieg; D. Laird (C. Jenkins 57’); L. Blane; A. Jeanes; C. Ledingham; A. Gibson; B. Heal; J. Burns (N. Tallen 57’); F. Moffett (F. Regan 85’); V. Thomas (S. Martin 66’); E. Walker (D. Brown 57’). Unused Subs: A Sutherland & L. Trotter.
Burntisland Shipyard; F. Russell (R. Couser 46’); M. Robertson (E. Jowitt 70’); S. Euler-Collinson; I. Marr; I. Millar; E. Bauld; J. Galloway (A. McAndrew 76’); D. Anthony (G. Allan 76’); J. Hunter (J. Hopton 70’); B. Anthony; M. Gibb. Unused subs: B. Couper; K. Beard; M. James.
Referee: C. Spalony.
